Rising Only Half the S&P’s Gain In 2023, Where Is BNY Mellon Stock Headed?

BNY Mellon stock (NYSE: BK) currently trades at $50 per share, around 22% below (28% upside) its level of $64 on February 9, 2022 (pre-inflation shock high), and seems undervalued. BNY Mellon saw its stock trading at around $42 at the end of June 2022, just before the Fed started increasing rates, and is trading 20% above that level now. In comparison, the S&P 500 gained about 23% during this period. The stock price has underperformed the broader index as the investors are cautiously optimistic toward the financial sector stocks due to the fear of potential recession and difficult macroeconomic conditions. This was despite the recovery in the net interest income driven by improvement in the interest rate environment.

Amid the current financial backdrop, BK stock has shown strong gains of 25% from levels of $40 in early January 2021 to around $50 now, vs. a similar change for the S&P 500 over this roughly 3-year period. However, the increase in BK stock has been far from consistent. Returns for the stock were 37% in 2021, -22% in 2022, and 10% in 2023 (YTD). In comparison, returns for the S&P 500 have been 27% in 2021, -19% in 2022, and 21% in 2023 (YTD) – indicating that BK underperformed the S&P in 2022 and 2023. In fact, consistently beating the S&P 500 – in good times and bad – has been difficult over recent years for individual stocks; for heavyweights in the Financial sector including V, JPM, and MA, and even for the megacap stars GOOG, TSLA, and MSFT.  In contrast, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio, with a collection of 30 stocks, has outperformed the S&P 500 each year over the same period. Why is that? As a group, HQ Portfolio stocks provided better returns with less risk versus the benchmark index; less of a roller-coaster ride as evident in HQ Portfolio performance metrics. Given the current uncertain macroeconomic environment with high oil prices and elevated interest rates, could BK face a similar situation as it did in 2022 and 2023 and underperform the S&P over the next 12 months – or will it see a strong jump?

Returning to the pre-inflation shock level means that BK stock will have to gain around 28% from the current levels. However, we do not expect that to materialize in the short term and estimate BNY Mellon’s valuation to be around $54 per share. 

Our detailed analysis of BNY Mellon’s upside post-inflation shock captures trends in the company’s stock during the turbulent market conditions seen over 2022 and compares these trends to the stock’s performance during the 2008 recession.

2022 Inflation Shock

Timeline of Inflation Shock So Far:

• 2020 – early 2021: Increase in money supply to cushion the impact of lockdowns led to high demand for goods; producers unable to match up.
• Early 2021: Shipping snarls and worker shortages from the coronavirus pandemic continue to hurt the supply
• April 2021: Inflation rates cross 4% and increase rapidly
• Early 2022: Energy and food prices spike due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Fed begins its rate hike process
• June 2022: Inflation levels peak at 9% – the highest level in 40 years. S&P 500 index declines more than 20% from peak levels.
• October 2022 – July 2023: Fed continues rate hike process; improving market sentiments help S&P500 recoup some of its losses
• Since July 2023: Fed keeps interest rates unchanged to quell fears of a recession, although another rate hike remains in the cards.

In contrast, here’s how BK stock and the broader market performed during the 2007/2008 crisis.

Timeline of 2007-08 Crisis

• 10/1/2007: Approximate pre-crisis peak in S&P 500 index
• 9/1/2008 – 10/1/2008: Accelerated market decline corresponding to Lehman bankruptcy filing (9/15/08)
• 3/1/2009: Approximate bottoming out of S&P 500 index
• 12/31/2009: Initial recovery to levels before accelerated decline (around 9/1/2008)

BK and S&P 500 Performance During 2007-08 Crisis

BNY Mellon stock declined from nearly $32 in September 2007 (pre-crisis peak) to below $22 in March 2009 (as the markets bottomed out), implying BK stock lost almost 31% of its pre-crisis value. It recovered post the 2008 crisis to levels of around $28 in early 2010, rising 26% between March 2009 and January 2010. The S&P 500 Index saw a decline of 51%, falling from levels of 1,540 in September 2007 to 757 in March 2009. It then rallied 48% between March 2009 and January 2010 to reach levels of 1,124.

BK Fundamentals Over Recent Years

BNY Mellon revenues decreased from $16.46 billion in 2019 to $15.81 billion in 2020 due to a drop in net interest income and fee income. However, it improved to $15.93 billion in 2021 and $16.38 billion in 2022. The growth was primarily driven by improvement in net interest income and fee revenues.

On the flip side, earnings decreased from $4.53 in 2019 to $2.91 in 2022 primarily due to higher expenses figure.

Conclusion

With the Fed’s efforts to tame runaway inflation rates helping market sentiments, we believe BNY Mellon (BK) stock has the potential for strong gains once fears of a potential recession are allayed.

[1] Month-to-date and year-to-date as of 12/13/2023
[2] Cumulative total returns since the end of 2016

Invest with Trefis Market-Beating Portfolios
See all Trefis Price Estimates